Skip to content

Plain-language guides to access to afterschool and summer learning

Date

Monday, November 16, 2026

Account

Posted by

Date

Summer Learning Loss: What the Research Says

summer learning loss

Worried your child will slip behind over the break? Summer learning loss is uneven: on average, scores flatten or drop, mostly in math, and strong summer programs can help.

For the bigger picture on who can reach programs outside school hours, see the guide to access to afterschool and summer learning.

Item Value
Average gap on return in the fall (RAND, 2011) About one month behind the spring level
Math drop, K-8 students, 2023 testing cycles About 10% to 30% of a typical school year’s learning
Reading change, 2023 testing cycles Average scores stayed nearly the same
Cost of a high-quality summer program $1,109 to $2,801 per student per summer
Cost compared with the school year About two-thirds

These figures come from the RAND research brief and from K-12 Dive’s May 14, 2026 report on NWEA data. Figures can change as new studies appear, so check the source before you rely on them.

What is summer learning loss?

Summer learning loss, often called the summer slide, is the loss of academic skills or knowledge during the months when school is out. According to NWEA’s April 23, 2026 post, researchers document it by comparing standardized test scores from near the end of spring with scores from the start of fall.

The worry is old. NWEA notes that concerns about students losing ground over summer go back at least a century, and RAND’s 2020 article describes a 1919 study that showed a clear decline in math performance over the summer.

Today the topic covers two separate questions: how far scores really drop, and whether summer break widens gaps between groups of students. NWEA describes both as long-standing questions that are still debated.

How big is the drop, and does it differ by subject?

The RAND research brief, published on June 13, 2011, reports that students return to school performing, on average, one month behind where they left off in the spring. The same brief adds that not all students experience average losses.

More recent figures point to a difference between subjects. In an analysis of 2023 spring and fall testing, reported by K-12 Dive, math drops for K-8 students equaled about 10% to 30% of a typical school year’s learning. Average reading scores over the same period stayed nearly the same.

NWEA’s suggested reason is that students may be more likely to read outside school than to practice math. It also says certain skills are particularly susceptible to gaps in practice:

  • Procedural skills
  • Vocabulary
  • Isolated facts
  • Multi-step tasks

These patterns come from one family of tests, and other tests paint a different picture, as the next section shows.

summer learning loss Summer reading
A person in a light-colored dress sits outdoors reading a book.

Why the evidence is still debated

NWEA’s review finds that results depend on the test. Studies using one national dataset show that learning slows down but does not drop over the summers after kindergarten and first grade, while studies using three interim and diagnostic assessments found far larger drops. As a result, NWEA says it remains uncertain whether the summer slide is a trivial issue or a serious challenge.

Findings on income gaps also differ. The 2011 RAND brief says summer learning loss disproportionately affects low-income students, who lose more ground in reading while higher-income peers may even gain. NWEA’s later review says the research community lacks consensus on whether summers disproportionately affect certain students.

A working paper by Atteberry and McEachin used over 200 million test scores to look at the full spread of losses across eight grades. It found dramatic variability, with losses building up for the same students over time. Family income and race together account for only about 4% of the variance in summer learning rates.

Researchers also admit limits. An NWEA researcher told K-12 Dive that the field cannot explain exactly why some students do much better over summer than others, partly because summer activities are hard to track.

Some researchers connect summer gaps to later outcomes. RAND’s 2020 article notes that more than three-quarters of high-income students have a four-year college degree by 25, against only around 10 percent of low-income students, and says summer learning gaps may help explain that difference.

What does research say about summer programs that work?

The 2011 RAND study found that students who attend summer programs can disrupt the loss and do better than peers who do not. In its press release, RAND said students gain the most when programs include individualized instruction, parental involvement and small class sizes.

The strongest test of this came from a long RAND study, described in the 2020 article. It tracked more than 5,000 children in five large districts who were about to become fourth-graders in the summer of 2013. The following fall, children invited to free summer programs showed an average math gain equal to around 15 percent of a typical school year.

After two summers, children who attended at least 20 days did better in math, reading and social and emotional outcomes, according to the same RAND article. It describes the most effective programs this way:

  • They recruit top teachers with grade-level experience and give them rigorous curriculums.
  • They run for five or six weeks, with three or four hours of academics a day plus enrichment.
  • They set a clear attendance policy, so children try to be there every day.

Results after the pandemic were smaller. NWEA reports that studies of programs in ten large districts in 2022 and 2023 found small positive impacts on math test scores (0.02 to 0.03 SD) but not on reading. Only 13% of students took part, and the programs averaged three to four weeks, while prior research suggests at least five weeks with at least three hours of instruction a day.

If you are comparing summer options with school-year ones, this explainer on what is an afterschool program sets out the basics.

What do summer programs cost, and who pays?

In the 2011 RAND brief, a high-quality program cost between $1,109 and $2,801 per student per summer, including food, transportation and facilities. Staffing is the key cost driver, so lowering the student-to-instructor ratio has significant cost implications.

RAND’s press release found that cost is the main barrier to starting and sustaining summer programs. It also notes that there are more than 100 funding sources that can support them. The brief adds that partnerships between districts and community-based organizations led to more varied programming and funding.

Pandemic-era money changed the picture for a time. NWEA estimates that $5.8 billion of ESSER funds had been spent on summer programs by September 2024, and that about 90% of districts offered an academic summer program in summer 2022.

To see how districts and communities piece funding together, read about afterschool program funding sources.

Frequently asked questions

How much do students lose over the summer?

Show answer

It depends on the subject, the test and the student. The 2011 RAND brief put the average at one month behind the spring level, while 2023 NWEA data showed math drops of about 10% to 30% of a school year and nearly unchanged reading.

Does summer learning loss hit low-income students hardest?

Show answer

The evidence is mixed. RAND’s 2011 brief says it disproportionately affects low-income students, but NWEA’s review says researchers lack consensus on whether summers disproportionately affect certain students.

How long should a summer program run to help?

Show answer

NWEA cites prior research suggesting at least five weeks with at least three hours of instruction a day. RAND’s 2020 article describes effective programs as running five or six weeks with three or four hours of academics daily.

Can families help at home?

Show answer

The RAND brief lists reading-at-home programs among the types of summer programs that benefit students. NWEA recommends that schools give families resources to support age-appropriate reading and math skill development.