Wondering whether your child’s time in a program will show up in report cards? Research on afterschool programs and academic achievement says it depends: academic programs can lift results when children attend regularly.
This guide sits within the wider topic of access to afterschool and summer learning, which looks at who can reach these programs.
| Key fact | Value |
|---|---|
| Youth who would enroll in an afterschool program if one were available | 19.4 million (parent survey estimate) |
| Share of people surveyed who opposed cutting public funding (2017 Quinnipiac poll) | 83 percent |
| Sports participation, low-income vs. wealthier families | 59 percent vs. 84 percent |
| Children aged five to fourteen in regular self-care (2005) | roughly 14 percent (5.2 million) |
| Hours of the day with the most concern about unsupervised children | roughly 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. |
These figures come from RAND’s perspective on out-of-school time programs and an NBER chapter on after-school care. Figures can change, so check the source before you rely on them.
Do afterschool programs raise grades and test scores?
RAND researchers reviewed rigorous, large-scale evaluations and meta-analyses of out-of-school time (OST) programs. Their overall conclusion was that OST programs are generally effective at producing the outcomes you would expect from their content and design, according to the RAND perspective.
For academics specifically, the same review found that academic OST programs can demonstrably improve academic outcomes. It also found that they do not necessarily reduce program attendance at the elementary level.
The evidence is not one-sided. RAND notes that advocates and critics alike can find studies that support or refute OST effectiveness, partly because programs with very different goals are often grouped together.
Why program content matters
A program that offers tutoring and a program that offers theater or sports are trying to do different things. RAND looked at programs through three lenses:
- Content: what children actually do during the program.
- Dosage: the hours of content provided.
- Outcomes: what the evaluation actually measures.
Economists writing for the National Bureau of Economic Research made a similar point in their chapter on after-school care. Programs that emphasize recreation may build self-esteem or physical fitness but may have a less significant effect on academic performance.
That is why RAND recommends that funders expect, and researchers measure, outcomes that align with program content. Judging a sports program by its reading scores, or a tutoring program only by its social benefits, gives a misleading picture.

How attendance and quality change the result
RAND’s key conclusions say that regular attendance matters: youth need to attend regularly to measurably benefit from programming. Its recommendations include that programs should work to maximize attendance of each individual student.
Quality matters too. The same review states that program quality and intentionality influence outcomes, and it recommends that funders support providers’ efforts to build intentional, high-quality programs.
State evaluations of federally funded programs ask these questions directly. The Michigan State University evaluation of the 2013-2014 program year tracks grades, teacher ratings, and student and parent perceptions. It also has a section asking whether students with greater participation had better academic outcomes.
What the 21st CCLC funding debate shows
The federal grant program is covered in more detail in the guide to 21st century community learning centers. RAND wrote its perspective while the President’s 2018 budget proposed eliminating the 21st Century Community Learning Centers grant, one of the largest funding sources that can be used for OST programs.
According to RAND, supporters of that cut pointed to ineffectiveness in raising academic performance. RAND countered that this position was largely based on one evaluation and did not consider program elements or other measures unrelated to academic achievement.
This is a useful reminder that a single study rarely settles the question. Neither a strong nor a weak result from one evaluation tells you how a different program, with different content and attendance, will perform.
How extended learning time compares
Afterschool programs are one form of added learning time. A meta-analysis of increased learning time programs, as summarized on a document-sharing page, reviewed 30 rigorous studies of their effects on student outcomes. For more on school-run versions, see the guide to extended learning time in schools.
The summary reports a split by teaching approach:
- Programs with certified teachers leading instruction, or a traditional instructional style, improved literacy and math achievement, though effects were small.
- Programs using experiential learning improved social-emotional skills but not academic achievement.
- Increased learning time benefited the literacy of below-standard students.
Because that page is a summary rather than the full report, treat the details as a starting point and read the original before relying on them.
Who benefits, and compared with what?
Context shapes results. The NBER chapter cautions that voluntary programs may have a limited effect if the alternative is simply supervised care at home rather than unsupervised self-care. The same chapter cites Census data showing roughly 14 percent of children aged five to fourteen were regularly in self-care in 2005, with concern centered on roughly 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. (NBER chapter).
Demand is also a factor. A parent survey cited by RAND estimated that 19.4 million youth not in an afterschool program would enroll if one were available, which suggests access limits who can benefit.
When you weigh a specific program, these questions follow from the research:
- Does it have academic content that matches the outcome you care about?
- Can your child attend regularly?
- Does the program describe how it builds quality and intentionality?
- Does it measure outcomes tied to what it actually teaches?
Frequently asked questions
Do all afterschool programs improve academic achievement?
Show answer
No. RAND found that programs are generally effective at the outcomes their content targets, and that academic programs can improve academic outcomes. A program built around recreation may help in other ways without moving grades much.
How much does attendance matter?
Show answer
A great deal, according to RAND: youth need to attend regularly to measurably benefit. Its recommendations call on programs to maximize each student’s attendance.
Do elementary students lose out if a program is academic?
Show answer
RAND found that academic OST programs do not necessarily reduce program attendance at the elementary level, so an academic focus does not by itself drive young children away.
Is the evidence settled?
Show answer
Not entirely. RAND notes that advocates and critics can each find evidence for their view, and it urges better measurement of quality and of outcomes that match program content. Check the original sources for the latest figures.
